Is Bing Better?

Even the wiki cultists over at Wikipedia know “Bing is a web search engine operated by Microsoft.” But if you’re not a Wikipedia geek, and chances are you’re not, since most of it’s user base is probably bots, what does it all mean for you?

“Is Bing better than Google?”, you might wonder. It’s a simple question, but there isn’t really a simple answer.

I reviewed Bing upon reading the announcement it was released.  In fact, I switched to it immediately.  I set it as default in the browser, and over the next few days Bing.com was my go-to-guy (or gal) for search. I was eager to give it a chance. Hell, I even gave Cuil a chance *shudder*. During that time, I found some things to love about Bing.  In the end, I switched back to Google, but barely, and for a reason I never would have predicted.

First, let’s talk about Bing’s advantages.

  • Does not promote SEO spam to the degree Google does
  • Results seem much more current
  • Special result format for certain types of searches
  • Shows your blog or web site a lot more love than Google (Unless you’re a spammer)

Bing is doing what Google should have come up with years ago, but in Google’s defense, they’ve been spending most of their time trying to take over the world, rather than tweak the search platform!

Bing is more relevant, more current, gives a better format for many searches, and it’s front page is actually accessible to the little guy, not a result of who bought the most links or page rank. These are not things to gloss over when it comes to search. They make for an overall better experience, and the more you use Google and see pages full of spam sites, the more you realize Bing has a role to play.

But…

  • Google’s interface is cleaner and perceptually simpler
  • Bing’s blue, white and orange b with a target in it symbol is annoying (at least to me)
  • Bing’s sidebar seems more like reserved advertisement space than anything useful
  • Bing’s spellchecking is inferior

Now, some of you might say that complaining about Bing’s look is pretty unfair, but it’s a visual internet, and Bing’s look is completely relevant.  There might really be some people out there who like it more, but I strongly favor the minimalist, clean interface of Google to Bing’s busier look. Sure the tri-color (if you count white) “bullseye ‘b'”, and the city scape taking up space in the top left corner might be nice eye candy…  presumably to comic book super hero fans, but it didn’t win me overBing b bullseye

Actually, I still really haven’t figured out what the lowercase “b” with the orange dot in it is supposed to be…  Why is it there? It seems impossible to find this graphic anywhere online, even though Microsoft has is using it as the favicon for the site. Maybe that means they’re not too attached to it, and might replace it with something better. Even just a plain (gold), stylistic b would be nice.

In the end, despite the other considerations above, it was one simple search that prompted me to go back to Google. I tried to pull up some information on Bing, not wanting to waste time checking the spelling, I put in a close approximation, and Bing had no results.  I put in the same name through Google, and it knew what I was looking for. As useful as Bing is, getting the “We did not find any results for…” message is a deal breaker for me, since I’ve come to rely on Google’s intuitive nature as far as spelling is concerned.

Sometimes I wonder if I made the right choice though. Sure, Bing cost me a few extra seconds on that one occasion, but how much time has Bing saved me when it comes to all the phishing sites and pornographic spam sites that seem to so easily creep onto Google’s 1st page results?  Every time I see traffic coming through on one word searches, I know they are from Bing.  You see, Bing puts relevant updated content on the first page, Google stacks malware sites and phishing sites upfront. Sure it’s the “algorithm” , but it’s also a choice to turn a blind eye to how they’re system is getting gamed.

Bing seems the more ethical choice…  I always feel just a little guilty when Bing sends me some nice traffic after posting an article.  It’s like choosing between two partners, and the one you left keeps reminding you that they exist and sending you little gifts.  Bing seems to be saying, “Look, just give me one more chance!” every time I check my statistics.  Bing is sending me more traffic and seemingly that traffic consists of more engaged users, than Google ever has.

In the long-run, if Bing keeps giving, I’m going to want to give back, and this could be the type of market strategy that really eats a hole through Google’s near-monopoly on search.  If you run a website or blog, you’re benefiting from Bing’s structure as a content provider, as well as a user.  Most of us can’t say the same with Google, unless we’re using the manipulative spamming techniques the internet has come to know and loathe.

Advertisements

3 thoughts on “Is Bing Better?

  1. In your description, you forgot “douchebag.”

    EDIT: Please everyone come see my uber leet SEO skillz and click on my site. I make money by saying “douchebag” in comments then people click my site LIKE A BOSS. I don’t get much money doing this, but ever since I lost my job as a psychiatrist, it’s really the only gig I can get.

  2. There are other problems with Bing, notably that the relevancy on Google is far better than Bing; but I am still with Bing because I like the interface, I don’t mind the logo (you’ll get used to it the way people got used to the weird colorful Google log — it took a while for me to get used to Google’s logo, too.) If Bing had the relevance of Google, the depth of Google, it would be a better experience. But I am in it for the long haul.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s